Part 2: Section 3

Prozac, Empathy, and Brain Systems

brain injection (part2 sec 2 pg2 ).jpg (9128 bytes)

© www.corbis.com

I would like to start out with a quote from Peter Kramer’s Listening to Prozac

“ The self, how it fares in a world where personality is understood as ‘biological and subject to biological influence, is a central issue for our time…Who are we, if we can be so altered by medication? ”

Peter Kramer, Listening to Prozac , pg. 332


What Peter Kramer did is somewhat remarkable considering his professional training as a traditional analyst coming from an era of psychoanalysts who are preoccupied with details of chemical interactions, neurotransmission, and genetic predispositions. He actually “listened” to his observations of patients taking Prozac. That is, through “talk therapy” he was able to probe something traditional scientists often shun from or simply reduce to biological materialism…the depth of the human “soul.”
He noticed that most of the people on Prozac became “better than well.” The pill made them want to talk about their experiences. In general it seemed to reduce separation anxiety by increasing empathy.
A working definition of empathy can be:

EMPATHY: The capacity for the action of understanding, being aware of, being sensitive to, and vicariously experiencing the feelings, thoughts and experiences of ANOTHER.

Definition from Merriam Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary


Kramer noticed that traditional explanations based on animal models and chemical levels were misleading his conception of the self. For instance, Kramer once had a patient in his office who after he has been given the pills was quite anxious. At first, Kramer attributed this to a common side effect of Prozac that includes nervousness or anxiety in the first couple of weeks. However, when he learned that the patient did not take the pills, he started to “listen” for the roots of the anxiety that seems to come from something deeper. Basically, the explanation for our capacity to feel and vicariously experience the feelings of another human being has to cover more ground that what the chemistry is willing to offer.

Brain part (part 2 sec 3).jpg (13560 bytes)

© www.corbis.com

Kramer hypothesized that Prozac is affecting certain AREAS OF THE BRAIN concerned with “feelings of abandonment.”That is, it is not simply a matter of neurotransmitter and other chemical involvement but a matter of a rather malleable material (think of it as a brain area) through which the emergence of something deeper occurs.

I want to make sure that I do not misuse this word in a traditional sense. What I mean by “the soul” is the broader concepts such as anxiety and feelings that are not just a result of the chemical interactions. Think back to the story of the patient I alluded to in the last paragraph. The patients “self” was in trouble and the way to understand that was to look at why it was so. We had to look at “the aboutness” of the problem.

It is important to note that the idea of a particular brain area processing a particular set of feelings concerned with, say interpersonal relations (which includes the feelings presented by empathy), is not so farfetched in neurobiology research. I already alluded to it in the section on Pheromones . That is, in the case of mating behavior of hamsters, there seemed to be brain centers that can be stimulated by chemicals such as pheromones or by learned behaviors, such as in the case of male hamsters who had previous encounters with a female. However, that is more of a speculation. More solid support for the notion of brain centers comes from the studies of cocaine effects on the brain.

COCAINE AND BRAIN SYSTEMS

brainscan.jpg (17565 bytes) brainscan2.jpg (11750 bytes)

Images © by Corbis.com

Most of the progress in this area is actually fairly resent. In the 1990’s brain imaging technology called functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) was developed. The usefulness of this technique is that it lets scientists visualize actual AREAS of the brain hypothesized to be active during a particular emotion, say the “rush” or “craving” aspects of drug abuse. Through fMRI studies (which show increased nerve activity in areas of brain when subject is rating their feelings as rush or craving) of cocaine addicts, scientists determined that certain parts of the brain are responsible for rush versus craving feelings associated with cocaine use. For details of the study go to http://www.drugabuse.gov/NIDA_Notes/NNVol13N5/Cocaine.html .
Also, it was discovered that brain systems, which are now termed Dopamine systems, are actual brain areas that are stimulated by certain drugs such as cocaine and heroine. From here came the hypothesis that these brain systems are responsible for information processing with regards to stimulus associated with pleasurable input or act.

CONCLUSIONS

part6levels.jpg (38193 bytes)

Photo by Rachel Berman

Kramer’s thesis is a wonderful starting hypothesis that is supported by some current scientific findings in brain research, particularly in cocaine usage. It thus adds to our chemical model to a great extent. Also, it is testable in some ways. That is, if we assume that there actually exist specific brain areas concerned with “feelings of abandonment” and interpersonal relations in general, a good experiment would be to examine cases when a person is incapable of having such relations. This is the subject of the next part in which I examine Autism .
The cover of Peter Kramer's book shows a man actually “taking off” his face off leaving behind a blank surface in its place. Questions such as what is the real self come into play here. I am not about to even try to answer such question, but at this point I can based on our discussion so far HYPOTHESIZE that

THERE ARE BRAIN CENTERS CONCERNED

WITH INTERPERSONAL RELATIONS


What happens when these are damaged or not developed is the subject of Part 3 .

LINKS on BRAIN SYSTEMS and COCAINE

Cocaine Activates Different Brain Regions for Rush Versus Craving
http://www.drugabuse.gov/NIDA_Notes/NNVol13N5/Cocaine.html

Center for Neural Bases of Cognition
http://www.cnbc.cmu.edu/announcements/schedules/April.2000/abstract.Montague.April.27.2000.html

The Use of Cocaine Causes Brain Lesions
http://www.epub.org.br/cm/n08/doencas/drugs/cocaine_i.htm

Monkeys on Cocaine Can Survive Repeated Brain Probes
http://www.vivisectioninfo.org/yerkesczoty.html

New Brain Studies Yield Insights Into Cocaine Binging
http://www.nida.nih.gov/MedAdv/MAs-yr96.html#11-29

Cocaine Dependence And Withdrawal: Neuroadaptive Changes In Brain
http://www.cocaine.org/cocabrain/index.html

Cocaine, Speed Changes Brain In Rats
http://www.personalmd.com/news/a1999050514.shtml



Index Introduction Part1 Part2 Part3 Part4 Part5 Part6




| Forum | Brain and Behavior | Serendip Home |

Send us your comments at Serendip

© by Serendip 1994- - Last Modified: Monday, 25-Nov-2002 21:32:53 EST