Serendip's Biology Forum

 

Welcome. This open forum is for postings and discussions relevant to Serendip's Biology resource page. Comments on materials linked to from there as well suggestions for additional materials are welcome here. Visit to find postings from others that you might find useful in your own thinking, and to leave postings that others might find useful. Postings may be delayed in appearing while they are checked to avoid spam.

Comments

newager's picture

Randomness and Freewill

Perhaps randomness is related to the concept of freewill? Nature is variable because of natural selection but maybe there is some other influence.

Gershom Zajicek M.D.'s picture

Does randomness exist in Nature?

Does randomness exist in Nature? Or is it only a tool to examine and interpret nature, like geometry with its points and lines that do not exist as such in nature. Or random numbers of mathematics which in computer models are represented by pseudo random numbers.

The concept of randomness is an essential ingredient of the exact sciences. Remove randomness from physics and you land in Aristotle’s world. On the other hand Life and randomness seems to me an oxymoron. Please note, that I am talking about Life and not Biology, which like physics cannot exist without randomness. Think of evolution, or randomly mutated genes that drive cancer. Yet Biology is a way to interpret nature and many of its statements are flawed since involving randomness.

Randomness is bad for your health and may even kill you. Medicine is driven by statistical models based on randomness which I call machine statistics. Like the central limit theorem which is not applicable to life phenomena. Yes, you may apply it to analyze disease, provide that you transform your observations accordingly. Unfortunately the human organism may not be transformed in the same way as dead matter. Nevertheless medicine applies such transformation in clinical trials when testing newly developed drugs, and there randomness is really dangerous for you.

So why is Biology so addicted to Randomness? Because it hides its ignorance. Life is complex and Biology attempts to simplify it. Whenever it fails it is rescued by randomness. Every statistical model applied by biology has a rescuing component, called random error (noise). It accounts for the discrepancy between model prediction an real life.

More on this painful topic, in my site

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
randomness