Submitted by Andrea G. on Tue, 03/04/2008 - 11:37am.
Hi Emily,
I think one of the great things about CBT is that it can account for individual differences so well. There are only so many different doses or variations on drugs that a psychiatrist can prescribe for treatment, but CBT is tailored to the individual. This still doesn't mean that it works for everyone; the studies show this very clearly, and just thinking about it abstractly, it's easy to see that a treatment that requires so much self-motivation and individual effort would be more effective for certain types of people.
Also, I'm wondering about your characterization of CBT as something you must recognize you have a disorder to undergo. I definitely agree with your statement, but I'm wondering why that's any different from getting a prescription and taking it. In going to a doctor for treatment, aren't you also acknowledging that you need some kind of help? You may not have a clinical diagnosis, but you've certainly admitted to yourself and to your doctor that something isn't right. In that respect, I think both treatment approaches are more similar than we might have thought.
»
Reply
Search Serendip
Narrative is determined not by a desire to narrate
but by a desire to exchange. (Roland Barthes, S/Z)
Individualizing treatment
Hi Emily,
I think one of the great things about CBT is that it can account for individual differences so well. There are only so many different doses or variations on drugs that a psychiatrist can prescribe for treatment, but CBT is tailored to the individual. This still doesn't mean that it works for everyone; the studies show this very clearly, and just thinking about it abstractly, it's easy to see that a treatment that requires so much self-motivation and individual effort would be more effective for certain types of people.
Also, I'm wondering about your characterization of CBT as something you must recognize you have a disorder to undergo. I definitely agree with your statement, but I'm wondering why that's any different from getting a prescription and taking it. In going to a doctor for treatment, aren't you also acknowledging that you need some kind of help? You may not have a clinical diagnosis, but you've certainly admitted to yourself and to your doctor that something isn't right. In that respect, I think both treatment approaches are more similar than we might have thought.