Silence in Eva's Man

sdane's picture

During my conference with Anne we talked about me doing something "creative" for my papers in the class, rather than a typical academic essay.  So, for my web event, I decided to write a haiku.

I was very drawn to the transitions throughout the book, so I decided to take the authors own words - the first set of words from the first three chapters - and put them together to form a haiku.  It is both written out below and in the attached file.

The police came and1

1. Throughout Eva’s Man, Eva’s relationship with the police and other positions of authority is marked by silence.  In many ways, this silence mirrors Eva’s interactions with other people in her life, including those who have hurt her, both physically and emotionally.  But while Eva’s silence and reluctance to tell her story seems to come out of a place of trauma, it is also a way for her to maintain agency and control in the face of a world where she has had little of either.  In this way, Eva’s silence is paradoxic: it is emotional and unconscious, and at the same time deliberate and forceful. Throughout Eva’s Man, Eva is asked to give a part of her self to others, usually sexually, and she often has no way of stopping them.  The people who ask Eva to speak,and tell her story recall these past traumas, and seem to trigger pain in Eva, which leads to her vulnerability and silence.  At the same time, however, being silent becomes a way for Eva to gain control by being able to make the decision not to share. 

Eva’s reluctance to share her story is often marked by literal silence, such as when she refuses to speak at the Detective Bureau’s Office (51), or when she refuses to divulge information about her dating life to Alfonso (58).  These interactions are themselves powerful, and by keeping all of her “stories” private, they become a way for Eva to protect herself against what others might do with her words.  Other times, however, Eva’s refusal to speak is loud.  She tells her psychiatrist, in a moment of questioning that conjures up memories of both Davis and her mother, “I don’t want to tell my story...why don’t you go away” (77).  Likewise, her silence with Davis is often very much articulated. Eva repeatedly tells him “I don’t like to talk about myself” and (73) “there’s nothing” (121), verbally expressing her ability to refuse him.Eva has been dominated and hurt by many people, and often seems to be passive in her spoken interaction, but her refusal to speak is just as radical as her violent action. 

What I remember about2

2.  Eva’s silence is also very much tied to the complicated role that memory and identity has throughout the book.  Eva relays her history in a stream-of-conscious manner, abruptly shifting from one period of her life to another.  At times, there seems to be a silence within her own head about what has occurred in the past, and confusion about how her life experiences have shaped her into being who she is today.  David asks Eva, “Who are you? Where did you come from?” and she replies by explaining that “Sometimes I wonder myself” (20).  The duality of Eva’s silence - an involuntary reaction to trauma and a way for her to assert control - is even further complicated by the fact that Eva herself seems unsure about what aspects of her life relate to one another, and what would be relevant in telling any specific “story.”  In some ways, an even stronger silence exists internally than in Eva’s interactions with other people.  She describes, for instance, Freddy Smoot looking her in the eyes right before he intended to rape her, and says “I didn’t know what he’d seen in my eyes, because I didn’t know what was there” (120).


Although there is no evidence that Eva’s memory is not intact, she does have a strong reaction to her psychiatrist’s concern that her memories are somehow skewed.  She explains, “I tell the psychiatrist what I remember. He tells me I do not know how to separate the imagined memories from the real ones” (10).  Later, she recalls him having a breakthrough, and telling Eva that Davis “came to represent all the men you’d known in your life” (81).  The psychiatrists reaction to this revelation is to say “ I got something out of you,” and Eva does not correct him.  It might, therefore, be impossible for Eva to tell a standard linear story about what occurred during any particular situation (including when she killed Davis), because no one moment can be isolated from the rest of her experiences.

A naked hanging3

3.  Eva relays many instances throughout the book when she is asked to to talk about herself by a variety of different people, but what almost all of these interactions have in common is that Eva is asked to speak about her sexuality and sexual experience.  Just as Eva is asked or forced to be sexually intimate with a long list of people in her life, all of these conversations require an incredible amount of intimacy.  Eva’s physical body has been violated and taken many times, but the act of requesting Eva to divulge these memories is also a form of violence against her.  Eva’s silence, therefore, is not just a way for her to maintain privacy and protect herself against unwanted attention, it is also a self-defense mechanism against real violence which would traumatize her even further.


Throughout the book, assumptions are made that Eva is willing and eager to be sexual without any consent coming from her.  She is referred to as a “savage woman” (141), conjuring up stereotypical images of black women who were thought of as wild and uncivilized, with unquenchable sexual appetites.  Eva’s silence becomes a way for the reader to see that, despite her very real sexual desire, she has limits on what she wants to do, and tries to mediate her sexual activity based on her own wants, not the requests of others.  This is especially important, given the many times that Eva’s verbal “no” has not  been heeded.  Eva tells Tyrone “I didn’t feel nothing,” but he insists, arguing  “you felt me and you can still feel me” (34).  Later, Moses Tripp refuses to listen to Eva’s “no” - at least until she stabs him in the hand.  Eva’s silence is a reaction to the pain from these events. It is a traumatic reaction to past suffering,  but it is also an important way regaining command.  It is a way of dealing with her complicated memories. Perhaps most importantly, it is a sign of autonomy and power despite past violations.  Eva is silent, but she is still strong.

AttachmentSize
Web event 4.pdf104.34 KB
Groups:

Comments

Anne Dalke's picture

"cutting"

Thanks, sdane,for explaining some of the back-story here. When you said, originally, that you were "very drawn to the transitions throughout the book," I thought you meant connections, not what you explain here: the "disjointed," "jarring" lack of transition throughout the novel.Your haiku, which is decidedly non-continuous, works well to represent that disjointedness.

This is a particularly striking experiment, given the essential characteristic of the haiku form (how much do you know about this?): that of "cutting," often represented by juxtaposing two images or ideas, with a "cutting word" between them, a kind of verbal punctuation mark which signals the moment of separation and colours the manner in which the juxtaposed elements are related.

Anne Dalke's picture

Making poetry?

sdane--
so I'm delighted that you decided to continue the creative experiments you initiated with your last web event, that little drama so filled with pauses and silences. (I do wish, though, that you would take some time to master the tricks of formatting your on-line work, to make it more accessible to others…it is easy, for example, to do footnotes on Serendip--scroll over the icons above, and right in the middle you'll see "superscript.")

I like this particular format--three short lines of a poem, w/ extended commentary; and I think your commentary about the novel (and Eva's character) is right on, really quite acute. What I'd like to explore a little more together, though, is the poem itself (which could go on your web page, even if the footnotes seem too unwieldly for you to manage...):

The police came and
What I remember about
A naked hanging

It's a clever conceit, to take the first set of words from the first three chapters, as the basis for a poem. But this one isn't working for me (I don't know whether another series of openings might work better....? Did you play w/ others....?) This one figures the gaps, for sure. But if anything we've been discovering about silence in this course holds true--the ways in which silence can "hold" meaning, for example, without it being articulated; and if the transitions that drew you in the book are operating here...

mightn't this have more coherence? Do you intend the jumpiness, the unfinishedness, the mystery? Tell me more...?



sdane's picture

I did like the idea of the

I did like the idea of the poem being disjointed, especially because I found the transitions (or, rather lack of transition) in general throughout the book to be pretty jarring, and at times pretty confusing.  Maybe it’s also because I've unconsciously internalized the one poem that showed its face every single year of elementary school.

Haikus are easy
but sometimes they don’t make sense
refrigerator

I did, however, initially want to take words from the first line of the book, from the middle of the book, and from the end of the book for my haiku.

The police came and
Here she said I said nothing
I leaned back squeezing

But then I changed my mind.  This was partly because I liked the way that the haiku using the first three chapters worked really well with ideas I felt I could offer a close reading of – Eva’s relationship with people in positions of authority, the complicated nature of Eva’s memory, and Eva’s sexual agency (even though the naked in the book was referring to a lamp).  I think I could have made my commentary work using any haiku, but it just seemed to fit really well with the lines I ended up choosing.  Even though they come together as a very disjointed poem.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
randomness