Therapy as Trauma
Haney's discussion of Visions tempted me to compare its problems to those of Alliance. Which was worse? Which group of women had more problems due to the instution's model of rehabilitation? I'm not quite sure why I felt so inclined to compare the two, as both had unique "visions" to make a rather unfortunate pun. Perhaps it's because when it comes to incarceration, we want to choose a model that does less harm than the current punitive role of most institutions. It's difficult to decide what "less harm" actually means--is it short term or long term? I worry that so many of these reformers with good intentions, similar to those who created ESP, seem to only create models with a set of unique challenges. The experience of being in a cage for hours is traumatic but so is the experience of being forced to share intense traumas with an audience. Like after reading Rigoberta Menchu's testimonial, I don't know quite what to do with the information I learned in Haney's book. I used to think that alternative models of incarceration were "the answer" or at least an answer, but I'm no longer so sure that they're actually better than prisons..